diff --git a/examples/results/q1_who_is_aldric.json b/examples/results/q1_who_is_aldric.json index ab90450..4e42f40 100644 --- a/examples/results/q1_who_is_aldric.json +++ b/examples/results/q1_who_is_aldric.json @@ -6,8 +6,8 @@ "turn": 0, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "I'll look up Aldric Raventhorne and his lineage in parallel.", - "reasoning_content": "The user is asking a type 1 question (\"who is X?\"). I should call `entity_context` to look up Aldric Raventhorne. I'll also call `lineage_of` to get his relations in parallel since both are independent.", + "content": "", + "reasoning_content": "The user is asking about Aldric Raventhorne - this is a question type 1 (\"who is X?\"). I should use the entity_context tool to look up this person and get their bio and relations.", "tool_calls": [ { "index": 0, @@ -15,16 +15,7 @@ "arguments": "{\"name\":\"Aldric Raventhorne\"}", "name": "entity_context" }, - "id": "call_function_jck40o8v16lb_1", - "type": "function" - }, - { - "index": 0, - "function": { - "arguments": "{\"person\":\"Aldric Raventhorne\"}", - "name": "lineage_of" - }, - "id": "call_function_jck40o8v16lb_2", + "id": "call_function_vmxe6v4l1kij_1", "type": "function" } ] @@ -39,10 +30,12 @@ "found": true, "name": "Aldric Raventhorne", "id": "aldric", + "world_id": "default", "labels": [ "Person" ], "properties": { + "world_id": "default", "tier": "noble", "culture": "Valdorni", "born": 220, @@ -51,6 +44,16 @@ "died": 285 }, "relations": [ + { + "rel": "POSSESSES", + "to_id": "pale_ledger", + "to": "The Pale Ledger" + }, + { + "rel": "MEMBER_OF", + "to_id": "crimson_pact", + "to": "The Crimson Pact" + }, { "rel": "POSSESSES", "to_id": "sword_eventide", @@ -73,41 +76,7 @@ } ] }, - "elapsed_ms": 35 - }, - { - "tool": "lineage_of", - "args": { - "person": "Aldric Raventhorne" - }, - "result": { - "person": "Aldric Raventhorne", - "lineage": "House Vyr (bloodline)", - "lineage_id": "house_vyr_bloodline", - "members": [ - { - "born": 160, - "name": "Cael Vyr", - "died": 240 - }, - { - "born": 220, - "name": "Aldric Raventhorne", - "died": 285 - }, - { - "born": 85, - "name": "Maric Vyr", - "died": 160 - }, - { - "born": 10, - "name": "Theron Ashveil", - "died": 120 - } - ] - }, - "elapsed_ms": 30 + "elapsed_ms": 5 } ] }, @@ -115,8 +84,8 @@ "turn": 1, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "**Aldric Raventhorne** (born 220 \u2013 died 285) was a noble of Valdorni culture. He was a member of **House Vyr** and belonged to the **House Vyr bloodline**. He was the wielder of the **Sword of Eventide** and the spouse of **Elara Raventhorne**.\n\nKnown members of his bloodline include:\n- **Cael Vyr** (160\u2013240)\n- **Maric Vyr** (85\u2013160)\n- **Theron Ashveil** (10\u2013120)", - "reasoning_content": "I have enough information to answer. Let me compile a brief bio and his known relations.\n\nAldric Raventhorne (id: aldric)\n- Born: 220, Died: 285\n- Tier: noble\n- Culture: Valdorni\n- Relations:\n - POSSESSES Sword of Eventide\n - MEMBER_OF House Vyr\n - SPOUSE_OF Elara Raventhorne\n - MEMBER_OF House Vyr (bloodline)\n- Lineage: House Vyr (bloodline)\n - Other members: Cael Vyr (160-240), Maric Vyr (85-160), Theron Ashveil (10-120)\n\nLet me give a concise answer.", + "content": "**Aldric Raventhorne** (220\u2013285) is a Valdorni noble. He is a member of **House Vyr** (and belongs to the House Vyr bloodline), and also holds membership in **The Crimson Pact**. He is married to **Elara Raventhorne** and possesses two notable items: the **Sword of Eventide** and **The Pale Ledger**.", + "reasoning_content": "Good, I have a clear picture. Let me give a concise bio.", "tool_calls": [] } } @@ -127,19 +96,11 @@ "args": { "name": "Aldric Raventhorne" }, - "elapsed_ms": 35, - "error": null - }, - { - "tool": "lineage_of", - "args": { - "person": "Aldric Raventhorne" - }, - "elapsed_ms": 30, + "elapsed_ms": 5, "error": null } ], - "answer": "**Aldric Raventhorne** (born 220 \u2013 died 285) was a noble of Valdorni culture. He was a member of **House Vyr** and belonged to the **House Vyr bloodline**. He was the wielder of the **Sword of Eventide** and the spouse of **Elara Raventhorne**.\n\nKnown members of his bloodline include:\n- **Cael Vyr** (160\u2013240)\n- **Maric Vyr** (85\u2013160)\n- **Theron Ashveil** (10\u2013120)", + "answer": "**Aldric Raventhorne** (220\u2013285) is a Valdorni noble. He is a member of **House Vyr** (and belongs to the House Vyr bloodline), and also holds membership in **The Crimson Pact**. He is married to **Elara Raventhorne** and possesses two notable items: the **Sword of Eventide** and **The Pale Ledger**.", "stopped_reason": "stop", "error": null, "evaluation": { diff --git a/examples/results/q2_was_allied_230.json b/examples/results/q2_was_allied_230.json index cd8276b..efda679 100644 --- a/examples/results/q2_was_allied_230.json +++ b/examples/results/q2_was_allied_230.json @@ -6,8 +6,8 @@ "turn": 0, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "I'll check the alliance between House Vyr and the Merchants Guild at that time.", - "reasoning_content": "The user is asking a question of type 2: \"was X true at time T?\" The relation is ALLIED_WITH between \"House Vyr\" (subject) and \"Merchants Guild\" (object) at time \"2nd_age.year_230\".\n\nI should call was_true_at with:\n- relation: ALLIED_WITH\n- subject: House Vyr\n- object: Merchants Guild\n- at_time: 2nd_age.year_230\n\nLet me also consider that I might need entity_context to verify these are the correct entity names, but was_true_at should handle that. Let me make the call.", + "content": "I'll check whether the ALLIED_WITH relation between House Vyr and the Merchants Guild held at that time.", + "reasoning_content": "The user is asking whether House Vyr was allied with the Merchants Guild at a specific time (2nd_age.year_230). This is a type 2 question: \"was X true at time T?\" I should use the `was_true_at` tool with the ALLIED_WITH relation.\n\nI need to identify the subject (House Vyr) and object (Merchants Guild). Let me call was_true_at with these parameters.", "tool_calls": [ { "index": 0, @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ "arguments": "{\"relation\":\"ALLIED_WITH\",\"subject\":\"House Vyr\",\"object\":\"Merchants Guild\",\"at_time\":\"2nd_age.year_230\"}", "name": "was_true_at" }, - "id": "call_function_5jbmc58cuve3_1", + "id": "call_function_zydg4wsu2kvt_1", "type": "function" } ] @@ -33,9 +33,10 @@ "was_true": true, "relation": "ALLIED_WITH", "valid_from": "2nd_age.year_100", - "valid_until": null + "valid_until": null, + "world_id": "default" }, - "elapsed_ms": 29 + "elapsed_ms": 6 } ] }, @@ -43,8 +44,8 @@ "turn": 1, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "Yes \u2014 House Vyr was allied with the Merchants Guild at 2nd_age.year_230. The ALLIED_WITH relationship was established in 2nd_age.year_100 and has no recorded end date, so it was in effect at that time.", - "reasoning_content": "The tool returned was_true: true, with valid_from \"2nd_age.year_100\" and no valid_until (open-ended). The query time 2nd_age.year_230 falls within this range, so the answer is yes.", + "content": "Yes. The ALLIED_WITH relation between House Vyr and the Merchants Guild was true at 2nd_age.year_230 \u2014 it had been in effect since 2nd_age.year_100 and has no recorded end date, so it was certainly active in year 230 of the 2nd Age.", + "reasoning_content": "The relation was true and has no end date, so it was certainly true at year 230.", "tool_calls": [] } } @@ -58,11 +59,11 @@ "object": "Merchants Guild", "at_time": "2nd_age.year_230" }, - "elapsed_ms": 29, + "elapsed_ms": 6, "error": null } ], - "answer": "Yes \u2014 House Vyr was allied with the Merchants Guild at 2nd_age.year_230. The ALLIED_WITH relationship was established in 2nd_age.year_100 and has no recorded end date, so it was in effect at that time.", + "answer": "Yes. The ALLIED_WITH relation between House Vyr and the Merchants Guild was true at 2nd_age.year_230 \u2014 it had been in effect since 2nd_age.year_100 and has no recorded end date, so it was certainly active in year 230 of the 2nd Age.", "stopped_reason": "stop", "error": null, "evaluation": { diff --git a/examples/results/q3_aldric_ancestors.json b/examples/results/q3_aldric_ancestors.json index d7165ca..2d4f684 100644 --- a/examples/results/q3_aldric_ancestors.json +++ b/examples/results/q3_aldric_ancestors.json @@ -6,25 +6,16 @@ "turn": 0, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "I'll look up Aldric Raventhorne's lineage. Let me pull his entity context, his bloodline membership, and his ancestors in parallel.", - "reasoning_content": "The user is asking about the lineage/ancestry of Aldric Raventhorne. This is question type 3: \"what is X's lineage?\" / \"who are X's ancestors?\". The primary tools are ancestors_of, descendants_of, and lineage_of.\n\nLet me start by calling entity_context to make sure I have the right person, and lineage_of to find the bloodline group, and ancestors_of to walk back as far as possible. I can do these in parallel since they don't depend on each other.", + "content": "I'll trace Aldric Raventhorne's ancestry. Let me first confirm the entity exists and pull his lineage group, then walk back through his ancestors.", + "reasoning_content": "The user is asking about the lineage/ancestry of \"Aldric Raventhorne\". This is question type 3 (\"what is X's lineage?\" / \"who are X's ancestors?\"). The primary tools are `ancestors_of`, `descendants_of`, `lineage_of`.\n\nLet me start by calling `ancestors_of` to walk back as far as possible. I should use a high number of generations, or I can try `lineage_of` first to confirm this person exists and see what lineage they belong to.\n\nLet me do both in parallel \u2014 call `ancestors_of` with a generous number of generations (say 10) and `lineage_of` to see the lineage group. I'll also use `entity_context` to verify the person exists and learn basic facts about them.\n\nActually, to be safe and avoid wasted calls, let me first confirm Aldric exists with entity_context, then call ancestors_of and lineage_of in parallel. But I can just call all three at once since they're independent \u2014 entity_context will tell me if the name doesn't resolve.\n\nLet me call all three in parallel.", "tool_calls": [ - { - "index": 0, - "function": { - "arguments": "{\"person\":\"Aldric Raventhorne\",\"generations\":10}", - "name": "ancestors_of" - }, - "id": "call_function_0xk5di2x26fz_3", - "type": "function" - }, { "index": 0, "function": { "arguments": "{\"name\":\"Aldric Raventhorne\"}", "name": "entity_context" }, - "id": "call_function_0xk5di2x26fz_1", + "id": "call_019ed316f96c7523a1f49e9b", "type": "function" }, { @@ -33,48 +24,21 @@ "arguments": "{\"person\":\"Aldric Raventhorne\"}", "name": "lineage_of" }, - "id": "call_function_0xk5di2x26fz_2", + "id": "call_019ed316f96c7523a1f49ea9", + "type": "function" + }, + { + "index": 0, + "function": { + "arguments": "{\"person\":\"Aldric Raventhorne\",\"generations\":10}", + "name": "ancestors_of" + }, + "id": "call_019ed316f96c7523a1f49ebb", "type": "function" } ] }, "tool_results": [ - { - "tool": "ancestors_of", - "args": { - "person": "Aldric Raventhorne", - "generations": 10 - }, - "result": { - "ancestors": [ - { - "name": "Theron Ashveil", - "born": 10, - "died": 120, - "id": "theron" - }, - { - "name": "Maric Vyr", - "born": 85, - "died": 160, - "id": "maric" - }, - { - "name": "Cael Vyr", - "born": 160, - "died": 240, - "id": "cael" - }, - { - "name": "Yssa Raventhorne", - "born": 165, - "died": null, - "id": "yssa" - } - ] - }, - "elapsed_ms": 42 - }, { "tool": "entity_context", "args": { @@ -84,10 +48,12 @@ "found": true, "name": "Aldric Raventhorne", "id": "aldric", + "world_id": "default", "labels": [ "Person" ], "properties": { + "world_id": "default", "tier": "noble", "culture": "Valdorni", "born": 220, @@ -96,6 +62,16 @@ "died": 285 }, "relations": [ + { + "rel": "POSSESSES", + "to_id": "pale_ledger", + "to": "The Pale Ledger" + }, + { + "rel": "MEMBER_OF", + "to_id": "crimson_pact", + "to": "The Crimson Pact" + }, { "rel": "POSSESSES", "to_id": "sword_eventide", @@ -118,7 +94,7 @@ } ] }, - "elapsed_ms": 6 + "elapsed_ms": 5 }, { "tool": "lineage_of", @@ -143,16 +119,54 @@ { "born": 85, "name": "Maric Vyr", - "died": 160 + "died": null }, { "born": 10, "name": "Theron Ashveil", - "died": 120 + "died": null } - ] + ], + "world_id": "default" }, - "elapsed_ms": 6 + "elapsed_ms": 5 + }, + { + "tool": "ancestors_of", + "args": { + "person": "Aldric Raventhorne", + "generations": 10 + }, + "result": { + "ancestors": [ + { + "name": "Theron Ashveil", + "born": 10, + "died": null, + "id": "theron" + }, + { + "name": "Maric Vyr", + "born": 85, + "died": null, + "id": "maric" + }, + { + "name": "Cael Vyr", + "born": 160, + "died": 240, + "id": "cael" + }, + { + "name": "Yssa Raventhorne", + "born": 165, + "died": 300, + "id": "yssa" + } + ], + "world_id": "default" + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4 } ] }, @@ -160,28 +174,246 @@ "turn": 1, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "I have the full chain. Here's the ancestry I can confirm from the graph:\n\n**Aldric Raventhorne** (b. 220, d. 285) \u2014 member of **House Vyr (bloodline)**\n\nWalking back through his known ancestors:\n\n- **Mother:** **Yssa Raventhorne** (b. 165, d. unknown)\n- **Maternal grandfather / paternal-side ancestor:** **Cael Vyr** (b. 160, d. 240) \u2014 House Vyr\n- **Cael's father:** **Maric Vyr** (b. 85, d. 160) \u2014 House Vyr\n- **Maric's father:** **Theron Ashveil** (b. 10, d. 120) \u2014 the furthest ancestor the graph records\n\nThe graph stops there \u2014 Theron Ashveil is the deepest recorded forebear (10\u2013120, late 1st Age / early 2nd Age). No further parents are linked. Note that **Yssa Raventhorne** is listed as a separate ancestor branch (the Raventhorne line), distinct from the Vyr patriline; I don't have a confirmed birth parent link between Yssa and Cael/Maric from this query, so the top of the tree is the Vyr line (Theron \u2192 Maric \u2192 Cael) plus the Raventhorne-line mother Yssa converging on Aldric.", + "content": "I have Aldric's lineage group and 4 generations of ancestors. Let me verify these are connected via PARENT_OF edges (the lineage list just shows bloodline members, not necessarily direct parents), and also walk back further to see if Theron Ashveil has any ancestors.", "reasoning_content": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "index": 0, + "function": { + "arguments": "{\"name\":\"Cael Vyr\"}", + "name": "entity_context" + }, + "id": "call_019ed31703e773029814e2a8", + "type": "function" + }, + { + "index": 0, + "function": { + "arguments": "{\"name\":\"Maric Vyr\"}", + "name": "entity_context" + }, + "id": "call_019ed31703e773029814e2b8", + "type": "function" + }, + { + "index": 0, + "function": { + "arguments": "{\"name\":\"Theron Ashveil\"}", + "name": "entity_context" + }, + "id": "call_019ed31703e773029814e2c3", + "type": "function" + }, + { + "index": 0, + "function": { + "arguments": "{\"name\":\"Yssa Raventhorne\"}", + "name": "entity_context" + }, + "id": "call_019ed31703e773029814e2da", + "type": "function" + } + ] + }, + "tool_results": [ + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Cael Vyr" + }, + "result": { + "found": true, + "name": "Cael Vyr", + "id": "cael", + "world_id": "default", + "labels": [ + "Person" + ], + "properties": { + "world_id": "default", + "tier": "noble", + "culture": "Valdorni", + "born": 160, + "name": "Cael Vyr", + "died": 240, + "id": "cael" + }, + "relations": [ + { + "rel": "PARENT_OF", + "to_id": "aldric", + "to": "Aldric Raventhorne" + }, + { + "rel": "MEMBER_OF", + "to_id": "house_vyr_bloodline", + "to": "House Vyr (bloodline)" + } + ] + }, + "elapsed_ms": 5 + }, + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Maric Vyr" + }, + "result": { + "found": true, + "name": "Maric Vyr", + "id": "maric", + "world_id": "default", + "labels": [ + "Person" + ], + "properties": { + "world_id": "default", + "tier": "noble", + "culture": "Valdorni", + "born": 85, + "name": "Maric Vyr", + "id": "maric" + }, + "relations": [ + { + "rel": "MEMBER_OF", + "to_id": "house_vyr", + "to": "House Vyr" + }, + { + "rel": "PARENT_OF", + "to_id": "cael", + "to": "Cael Vyr" + }, + { + "rel": "MEMBER_OF", + "to_id": "house_vyr_bloodline", + "to": "House Vyr (bloodline)" + } + ] + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4 + }, + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Theron Ashveil" + }, + "result": { + "found": true, + "name": "Theron Ashveil", + "id": "theron", + "world_id": "default", + "labels": [ + "Person" + ], + "properties": { + "world_id": "default", + "tier": "noble", + "culture": "Valdorni", + "born": 10, + "name": "Theron Ashveil", + "id": "theron" + }, + "relations": [ + { + "rel": "PARENT_OF", + "to_id": "maric", + "to": "Maric Vyr" + }, + { + "rel": "MEMBER_OF", + "to_id": "house_vyr_bloodline", + "to": "House Vyr (bloodline)" + } + ] + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4 + }, + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Yssa Raventhorne" + }, + "result": { + "found": true, + "name": "Yssa Raventhorne", + "id": "yssa", + "world_id": "default", + "labels": [ + "Person" + ], + "properties": { + "world_id": "default", + "tier": "noble", + "culture": "Valdorni", + "born": 165, + "name": "Yssa Raventhorne", + "died": 300, + "id": "yssa" + }, + "relations": [ + { + "rel": "PARENT_OF", + "to_id": "aldric", + "to": "Aldric Raventhorne" + } + ] + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4 + } + ] + }, + { + "turn": 2, + "assistant": { + "role": "assistant", + "content": "I have the full ancestral chain confirmed via PARENT_OF edges. Let me also check if Theron Ashveil has any further ancestors (parents), since the ancestry walk might have hit the limit.", + "reasoning_content": null, + "tool_calls": [ + { + "index": 0, + "function": { + "arguments": "{\"generations\":5,\"person\":\"Theron Ashveil\"}", + "name": "ancestors_of" + }, + "id": "call_019ed3170a7e77c298efd86f", + "type": "function" + } + ] + }, + "tool_results": [ + { + "tool": "ancestors_of", + "args": { + "generations": 5, + "person": "Theron Ashveil" + }, + "result": { + "ancestors": [], + "world_id": "default" + }, + "elapsed_ms": 5 + } + ] + }, + { + "turn": 3, + "assistant": { + "role": "assistant", + "content": "## Aldric Raventhorne \u2014 Ancestry\n\nAldric Raventhorne (b. 220, d. 285) belongs to the **House Vyr** bloodline. Here is the known ancestral chain, walking back as far as the graph records:\n\n| Generation | Ancestor | Born | Died | Edge to Aldric |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 (parents) | **Cael Vyr** | 160 | 240 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Aldric |\n| 1 (parents) | **Yssa Raventhorne** | 165 | 300 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Aldric |\n| 2 (paternal) | **Maric Vyr** | 85 | \u2014 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Cael |\n| 3 (paternal) | **Theron Ashveil** | 10 | \u2014 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Maric |\n\nTheron Ashveil has no recorded parents, so he is the **founding root of House Vyr** as recorded in the world graph.\n\nA couple of notes worth flagging:\n- **Yssa Raventhorne** (Aldric's mother) carries the Raventhorne name but is *not* a member of the \"House Vyr (bloodline)\" lineage group in the graph \u2014 only Cael, Maric, Theron, and Aldric are. The Raventhorne surname therefore appears to enter the line through her rather than the Vyr paternal line.\n- The chain covers **4 generations** back from Aldric; nothing further exists for Theron Ashveil, so the graph cannot trace the line earlier than that.", + "reasoning_content": "Theron Ashveil has no known parents in the graph \u2014 he's the root of this lineage. So the full chain is:\n\n- Aldric Raventhorne (b. 220, d. 285) \u2014 son of Cael Vyr and Yssa Raventhorne\n- Cael Vyr (b. 160, d. 240) \u2014 father\n- Yssa Raventhorne (b. 165, d. 300) \u2014 mother (no lineage group attached, but a direct PARENT_OF)\n- Maric Vyr (b. 85) \u2014 paternal grandfather\n- Theron Ashveil (b. 10) \u2014 paternal great-grandfather (founder/root of the line)\n\nThat's 4 generations. The lineage group is \"House Vyr (bloodline)\" with 4 members: Theron, Maric, Cael, Aldric. Yssa is a direct parent but isn't listed as a member of that bloodline group \u2014 that's worth noting since she has the \"Raventhorne\" surname.\n\nLet me give a clean concise answer.", "tool_calls": [] } } ], "tools_called": [ - { - "tool": "ancestors_of", - "args": { - "person": "Aldric Raventhorne", - "generations": 10 - }, - "elapsed_ms": 42, - "error": null - }, { "tool": "entity_context", "args": { "name": "Aldric Raventhorne" }, - "elapsed_ms": 6, + "elapsed_ms": 5, "error": null }, { @@ -189,11 +421,61 @@ "args": { "person": "Aldric Raventhorne" }, - "elapsed_ms": 6, + "elapsed_ms": 5, + "error": null + }, + { + "tool": "ancestors_of", + "args": { + "person": "Aldric Raventhorne", + "generations": 10 + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4, + "error": null + }, + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Cael Vyr" + }, + "elapsed_ms": 5, + "error": null + }, + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Maric Vyr" + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4, + "error": null + }, + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Theron Ashveil" + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4, + "error": null + }, + { + "tool": "entity_context", + "args": { + "name": "Yssa Raventhorne" + }, + "elapsed_ms": 4, + "error": null + }, + { + "tool": "ancestors_of", + "args": { + "generations": 5, + "person": "Theron Ashveil" + }, + "elapsed_ms": 5, "error": null } ], - "answer": "I have the full chain. Here's the ancestry I can confirm from the graph:\n\n**Aldric Raventhorne** (b. 220, d. 285) \u2014 member of **House Vyr (bloodline)**\n\nWalking back through his known ancestors:\n\n- **Mother:** **Yssa Raventhorne** (b. 165, d. unknown)\n- **Maternal grandfather / paternal-side ancestor:** **Cael Vyr** (b. 160, d. 240) \u2014 House Vyr\n- **Cael's father:** **Maric Vyr** (b. 85, d. 160) \u2014 House Vyr\n- **Maric's father:** **Theron Ashveil** (b. 10, d. 120) \u2014 the furthest ancestor the graph records\n\nThe graph stops there \u2014 Theron Ashveil is the deepest recorded forebear (10\u2013120, late 1st Age / early 2nd Age). No further parents are linked. Note that **Yssa Raventhorne** is listed as a separate ancestor branch (the Raventhorne line), distinct from the Vyr patriline; I don't have a confirmed birth parent link between Yssa and Cael/Maric from this query, so the top of the tree is the Vyr line (Theron \u2192 Maric \u2192 Cael) plus the Raventhorne-line mother Yssa converging on Aldric.", + "answer": "## Aldric Raventhorne \u2014 Ancestry\n\nAldric Raventhorne (b. 220, d. 285) belongs to the **House Vyr** bloodline. Here is the known ancestral chain, walking back as far as the graph records:\n\n| Generation | Ancestor | Born | Died | Edge to Aldric |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 (parents) | **Cael Vyr** | 160 | 240 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Aldric |\n| 1 (parents) | **Yssa Raventhorne** | 165 | 300 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Aldric |\n| 2 (paternal) | **Maric Vyr** | 85 | \u2014 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Cael |\n| 3 (paternal) | **Theron Ashveil** | 10 | \u2014 | PARENT_OF \u2192 Maric |\n\nTheron Ashveil has no recorded parents, so he is the **founding root of House Vyr** as recorded in the world graph.\n\nA couple of notes worth flagging:\n- **Yssa Raventhorne** (Aldric's mother) carries the Raventhorne name but is *not* a member of the \"House Vyr (bloodline)\" lineage group in the graph \u2014 only Cael, Maric, Theron, and Aldric are. The Raventhorne surname therefore appears to enter the line through her rather than the Vyr paternal line.\n- The chain covers **4 generations** back from Aldric; nothing further exists for Theron Ashveil, so the graph cannot trace the line earlier than that.", "stopped_reason": "stop", "error": null, "evaluation": { diff --git a/examples/results/q4_images_of_aldric.json b/examples/results/q4_images_of_aldric.json index fa00648..4f24f8b 100644 --- a/examples/results/q4_images_of_aldric.json +++ b/examples/results/q4_images_of_aldric.json @@ -6,8 +6,8 @@ "turn": 0, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "I'll look up Aldric Raventhorne in the world graph and then recall any images linked to him.", - "reasoning_content": "The user wants to see images of Aldric Raventhorne. This is a question type 4 (\"show me images of X\"). I should first get the entity context to find Aldric's entity_id, then use recall_images to fetch images associated with him.", + "content": "I'll look up Aldric Raventhorne to get his entity ID, then pull his images.", + "reasoning_content": "The user wants images of Aldric Raventhorne. This is a question type 4 (show me images of X). I should use recall_images to fetch images for that entity. Let me start by getting the entity context to find the correct entity_id, then call recall_images. Actually, recall_images takes entity_id directly, but I need to know the entity_id. Let me first check entity_context to find the id, or I could use search_images_by_caption as a fallback.\n\nLet me start with entity_context to identify Aldric Raventhorne, and in parallel I can try search_images_by_caption as a backup. Actually, recall_images needs entity_id, so let me first get entity_context.", "tool_calls": [ { "index": 0, @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ "arguments": "{\"name\":\"Aldric Raventhorne\"}", "name": "entity_context" }, - "id": "call_function_rfj2dvn5xlcn_1", + "id": "call_function_v7idyvqncjvy_1", "type": "function" } ] @@ -30,10 +30,12 @@ "found": true, "name": "Aldric Raventhorne", "id": "aldric", + "world_id": "default", "labels": [ "Person" ], "properties": { + "world_id": "default", "tier": "noble", "culture": "Valdorni", "born": 220, @@ -42,6 +44,16 @@ "died": 285 }, "relations": [ + { + "rel": "POSSESSES", + "to_id": "pale_ledger", + "to": "The Pale Ledger" + }, + { + "rel": "MEMBER_OF", + "to_id": "crimson_pact", + "to": "The Crimson Pact" + }, { "rel": "POSSESSES", "to_id": "sword_eventide", @@ -64,7 +76,7 @@ } ] }, - "elapsed_ms": 8 + "elapsed_ms": 6 } ] }, @@ -73,7 +85,7 @@ "assistant": { "role": "assistant", "content": "", - "reasoning_content": "Good, found Aldric. Now let me recall images linked to him.", + "reasoning_content": null, "tool_calls": [ { "index": 0, @@ -81,7 +93,7 @@ "arguments": "{\"entity_id\":\"aldric\"}", "name": "recall_images" }, - "id": "call_function_m82n67wlk596_1", + "id": "call_function_3uhgmx5vv3gi_1", "type": "function" } ] @@ -94,10 +106,22 @@ }, "result": { "entity_id": "aldric", - "count": 1, + "world_id": "default", + "count": 2, "images": [ + { + "image_id": "img_test", + "world_id": "default", + "caption": "test image", + "tags": [ + "test" + ], + "era": "2nd_age", + "presigned_url": "http://localhost:9000/lore-images/test/x.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260617%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260617T005934Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=a5fee2f91c5c73f911a6bcc3aed1191a8519a60f786f6fcb78f6ba78a247e3ce" + }, { "image_id": "img_aldric_portrait", + "world_id": "default", "caption": "Portrait of Aldric Raventhorne, Lord of Thornwall. Middle-aged, dark hair, a scar above the left eye.", "tags": [ "portrait", @@ -105,11 +129,11 @@ "thornwall" ], "era": "2nd_age", - "presigned_url": "http://localhost:9000/lore-images/characters/aldric_portrait.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260616%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260616T224707Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=5eb05aa2c0711d88854069bbbf314d7be44ae04cd6b8e83a2d196131dbd19aaf" + "presigned_url": "http://localhost:9000/lore-images/characters/aldric_portrait.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260617%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260617T005934Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=cf5a667e9a23fb1ecea8aa4ba28e23021d9e709c4705f837c3345cd6a79dff6a" } ] }, - "elapsed_ms": 190 + "elapsed_ms": 12 } ] }, @@ -117,7 +141,7 @@ "turn": 2, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "Found one image for Aldric Raventhorne:\n\n**Portrait of Aldric Raventhorne, Lord of Thornwall** (`img_aldric_portrait`)\n- Era: 2nd Age\n- Caption: \"Portrait of Aldric Raventhorne, Lord of Thornwall. Middle-aged, dark hair, a scar above the left eye.\"\n- Tags: portrait, noble, thornwall\n\nURL: http://localhost:9000/lore-images/characters/aldric_portrait.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260616%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260616T224707Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=5eb05aa2c0711d88854069bbbf314d7be44ae04cd6b8e83a2d196131dbd19aaf\n\nFor context: Aldric Raventhorne (2nd Age, 220\u2013285) was a Valdorni noble, head of House Vyr, spouse of Elara Raventhorne, and bearer of the Sword of Eventide. Only the one portrait is currently registered for him \u2014 no other portraits, battle scenes, or related images are on file. If you'd like, I can also run a caption-based search (e.g. for \"scarred noble\" or \"Thornwall lord\") to see if any untagged images of him exist in the archive.", + "content": "I found 2 images for Aldric Raventhorne (entity `aldric`, a Valdorni noble of House Vyr, b. 220 \u2013 d. 285):\n\n1. **`img_aldric_portrait`** \u2014 *Portrait of Aldric Raventhorne, Lord of Thornwall. Middle-aged, dark hair, a scar above the left eye.* Tagged `portrait`, `noble`, `thornwall`. [View image](http://localhost:9000/lore-images/characters/aldric_portrait.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260617%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260617T005934Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=cf5a667e9a23fb1ecea8aa4ba28e23021d9e709c4705f837c3345cd6a79dff6a)\n\n2. **`img_test`** \u2014 captioned only as \"test image\", tagged `test`. This looks like a placeholder/seed image rather than real artwork. [View image](http://localhost:9000/lore-images/test/x.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260617%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260617T005934Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=a5fee2f91c5c73f911a6bcc3aed1191a8519a60f786f6fcb78f6ba78a247e3ce)\n\nOnly the first is a real portrait. The second appears to be a test artifact still linked to his entity \u2014 you may want to unlink it.", "reasoning_content": null, "tool_calls": [] } @@ -129,7 +153,7 @@ "args": { "name": "Aldric Raventhorne" }, - "elapsed_ms": 8, + "elapsed_ms": 6, "error": null }, { @@ -137,11 +161,11 @@ "args": { "entity_id": "aldric" }, - "elapsed_ms": 190, + "elapsed_ms": 12, "error": null } ], - "answer": "Found one image for Aldric Raventhorne:\n\n**Portrait of Aldric Raventhorne, Lord of Thornwall** (`img_aldric_portrait`)\n- Era: 2nd Age\n- Caption: \"Portrait of Aldric Raventhorne, Lord of Thornwall. Middle-aged, dark hair, a scar above the left eye.\"\n- Tags: portrait, noble, thornwall\n\nURL: http://localhost:9000/lore-images/characters/aldric_portrait.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260616%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260616T224707Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=5eb05aa2c0711d88854069bbbf314d7be44ae04cd6b8e83a2d196131dbd19aaf\n\nFor context: Aldric Raventhorne (2nd Age, 220\u2013285) was a Valdorni noble, head of House Vyr, spouse of Elara Raventhorne, and bearer of the Sword of Eventide. Only the one portrait is currently registered for him \u2014 no other portraits, battle scenes, or related images are on file. If you'd like, I can also run a caption-based search (e.g. for \"scarred noble\" or \"Thornwall lord\") to see if any untagged images of him exist in the archive.", + "answer": "I found 2 images for Aldric Raventhorne (entity `aldric`, a Valdorni noble of House Vyr, b. 220 \u2013 d. 285):\n\n1. **`img_aldric_portrait`** \u2014 *Portrait of Aldric Raventhorne, Lord of Thornwall. Middle-aged, dark hair, a scar above the left eye.* Tagged `portrait`, `noble`, `thornwall`. [View image](http://localhost:9000/lore-images/characters/aldric_portrait.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260617%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260617T005934Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=cf5a667e9a23fb1ecea8aa4ba28e23021d9e709c4705f837c3345cd6a79dff6a)\n\n2. **`img_test`** \u2014 captioned only as \"test image\", tagged `test`. This looks like a placeholder/seed image rather than real artwork. [View image](http://localhost:9000/lore-images/test/x.png?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Credential=lorelore%2F20260617%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20260617T005934Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Signature=a5fee2f91c5c73f911a6bcc3aed1191a8519a60f786f6fcb78f6ba78a247e3ce)\n\nOnly the first is a real portrait. The second appears to be a test artifact still linked to his entity \u2014 you may want to unlink it.", "stopped_reason": "stop", "error": null, "evaluation": { diff --git a/examples/results/q5_consistency_issues.json b/examples/results/q5_consistency_issues.json index a245506..ad0a47b 100644 --- a/examples/results/q5_consistency_issues.json +++ b/examples/results/q5_consistency_issues.json @@ -6,8 +6,8 @@ "turn": 0, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "I'll check all four consistency dimensions in parallel.", - "reasoning_content": "The user is asking a type-5 question: \"what are the open consistency issues?\" I should call all four consistency tools in parallel since they're independent.", + "content": "I'll check all four consistency categories in parallel since they're independent checks.", + "reasoning_content": "The user wants me to check the world graph for open consistency issues across all four categories: contradictions, anachronisms, orphans, and ontology violations. I'll call all four tools in parallel since they're independent.", "tool_calls": [ { "index": 0, @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ "arguments": "{}", "name": "find_contradictions" }, - "id": "call_G7NLfQzCwUeRKZm0FGxkDFO3", + "id": "call_UleQ8N7Y0vBnMyv1GCD4ejuL", "type": "function" }, { @@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ "arguments": "{}", "name": "find_anachronisms" }, - "id": "call_jpT6AjwqTZnBIZtEAeEavBkr", + "id": "call_8b67s712EPgO9IJgKrPNFg06", "type": "function" }, { @@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ "arguments": "{}", "name": "find_orphans" }, - "id": "call_gDb0ST6zit5OVHMjzmm6cGti", + "id": "call_GUndauWEeTQiTYQ1AbTUAgU3", "type": "function" }, { @@ -42,7 +42,7 @@ "arguments": "{}", "name": "find_ontology_violations" }, - "id": "call_xJYovr8dJ9jN5WynMFbu8cUL", + "id": "call_gsnpmeZZYoYB4bw4CRUwb9O9", "type": "function" } ] @@ -52,37 +52,85 @@ "tool": "find_contradictions", "args": {}, "result": { - "violations": [], - "count": 0 + "violations": [ + { + "id": "c_aldric_double_membership", + "label": "Contradiction", + "severity": "error", + "status": "open", + "details": "Aldric Raventhorne is MEMBER_OF House Vyr (240-) and MEMBER_OF Crimson Pact (260-285); the two memberships overlap.", + "detected_at": "2026-06-17T00:58:34.137692Z" + } + ], + "count": 1 }, - "elapsed_ms": 7 + "elapsed_ms": 5 }, { "tool": "find_anachronisms", "args": {}, "result": { - "violations": [], - "count": 0 + "violations": [ + { + "id": "a_vex_at_founding", + "label": "Anachronism", + "severity": "error", + "status": "open", + "details": "Vex the Silent (born 180) is recorded as participating in the Founding of House Vyr (year 85) \u2014 95 years before his birth.", + "detected_at": "2026-06-17T00:58:34.137692Z" + } + ], + "count": 1 }, - "elapsed_ms": 6 + "elapsed_ms": 3 }, { "tool": "find_orphans", "args": {}, "result": { - "violations": [], - "count": 0 + "violations": [ + { + "id": "o_unfinished_npc", + "label": "Orphan", + "severity": "warn", + "status": "open", + "details": "Person 'Lyssa the Watcher' exists but has no relations \u2014 world-builder placeholder, not yet connected.", + "detected_at": "2026-06-17T00:58:34.137692Z" + } + ], + "count": 1 }, - "elapsed_ms": 4 + "elapsed_ms": 3 }, { "tool": "find_ontology_violations", "args": {}, "result": { - "violations": [], - "count": 0 + "violations": [ + { + "id": "ov_maric_no_died", + "label": "OntologyViolation", + "severity": "warn", + "status": "open", + "details": "Person 'Maric Vyr' (born 85) has no death year; rule 'persons_born_before_280_must_die' applies.", + "detected_at": "2026-06-17T00:58:34.137692Z", + "entity_id": "maric", + "rule_id": "persons_born_before_280_must_die" + }, + { + "id": "ov_theron_no_died", + "label": "OntologyViolation", + "severity": "warn", + "status": "open", + "details": "Person 'Theron Ashveil' (born 10) has no death year; rule 'persons_born_before_280_must_die' applies.", + "detected_at": "2026-06-17T00:58:34.137692Z", + "entity_id": "theron", + "rule_id": "persons_born_before_280_must_die" + } + ], + "count": 2 }, - "elapsed_ms": 4 + "elapsed_ms": 3 } ] }, @@ -90,8 +138,8 @@ "turn": 1, "assistant": { "role": "assistant", - "content": "**No open consistency issues detected.** All four consistency checks returned zero violations:\n\n- **Contradictions**: 0 \u2014 no two sources are making incompatible claims about the same fact.\n- **Anachronisms**: 0 \u2014 no claims place a person, faction, or thing at a time it couldn't exist.\n- **Orphans**: 0 \u2014 every entity is connected to the rest of the graph.\n- **Ontology violations**: 0 \u2014 no graph states violate the world's domain rules.\n\nPer the harness docs, these detection rules may be stubs, so an empty result here means \"nothing the rules currently know about,\" not necessarily \"the world is provably consistent.\" If you suspect a specific issue, point me at it and I can drill into the entities involved.", - "reasoning_content": "All four consistency checks returned empty results. Per the protocol, when the tools return zero violations, I should report that honestly rather than fabricate issues.", + "content": "Here are the open consistency issues across the four checkers \u2014 all four have findings, totaling **5 issues** (2 errors, 3 warnings):\n\n### Contradictions (1 error)\n- **`c_aldric_double_membership`** \u2014 Aldric Raventhorne is `MEMBER_OF` House Vyr (from year 240) and `MEMBER_OF` Crimson Pact (260\u2013285); the two memberships overlap during 260\u2013285.\n\n### Anachronisms (1 error)\n- **`a_vex_at_founding`** \u2014 Vex the Silent (born year 180) is recorded as participating in the Founding of House Vyr (year 85) \u2014 95 years before his birth.\n\n### Orphans (1 warning)\n- **`o_unfinished_npc`** \u2014 Person \"Lyssa the Watcher\" exists with zero relations. Likely a world-builder placeholder.\n\n### Ontology Violations (2 warnings, same rule)\nRule `persons_born_before_280_must_die` is failing on two people who have no `died` year:\n- **`ov_maric_no_died`** \u2014 Maric Vyr (born 85)\n- **`ov_theron_no_died`** \u2014 Theron Ashveil (born 10)\n\n### Suggested priority\nThe two **errors** should be fixed first: resolve Aldric's overlapping faction memberships (decide which one applies during 260\u2013285), and correct Vex's presence at the Founding of House Vyr (either move the event, change Vex's birth year, or attribute the event to someone else alive in year 85).", + "reasoning_content": "I have all four results. Let me summarize them concisely as instructed (2-4 sentences plus relevant facts).\n\nContradictions: 1 error - Aldric has overlapping memberships in House Vyr (240-) and Crimson Pact (260-285).\nAnachronisms: 1 error - Vex the Silent (born 180) at the Founding of House Vyr (year 85).\nOrphans: 1 warn - Lyssa the Watcher has no relations.\nOntology violations: 2 warns - Maric Vyr and Theron Ashveil have no death year but rule says persons born before 280 must die.\n\nLet me compose a concise summary.", "tool_calls": [] } } @@ -100,29 +148,29 @@ { "tool": "find_contradictions", "args": {}, - "elapsed_ms": 7, + "elapsed_ms": 5, "error": null }, { "tool": "find_anachronisms", "args": {}, - "elapsed_ms": 6, + "elapsed_ms": 3, "error": null }, { "tool": "find_orphans", "args": {}, - "elapsed_ms": 4, + "elapsed_ms": 3, "error": null }, { "tool": "find_ontology_violations", "args": {}, - "elapsed_ms": 4, + "elapsed_ms": 3, "error": null } ], - "answer": "**No open consistency issues detected.** All four consistency checks returned zero violations:\n\n- **Contradictions**: 0 \u2014 no two sources are making incompatible claims about the same fact.\n- **Anachronisms**: 0 \u2014 no claims place a person, faction, or thing at a time it couldn't exist.\n- **Orphans**: 0 \u2014 every entity is connected to the rest of the graph.\n- **Ontology violations**: 0 \u2014 no graph states violate the world's domain rules.\n\nPer the harness docs, these detection rules may be stubs, so an empty result here means \"nothing the rules currently know about,\" not necessarily \"the world is provably consistent.\" If you suspect a specific issue, point me at it and I can drill into the entities involved.", + "answer": "Here are the open consistency issues across the four checkers \u2014 all four have findings, totaling **5 issues** (2 errors, 3 warnings):\n\n### Contradictions (1 error)\n- **`c_aldric_double_membership`** \u2014 Aldric Raventhorne is `MEMBER_OF` House Vyr (from year 240) and `MEMBER_OF` Crimson Pact (260\u2013285); the two memberships overlap during 260\u2013285.\n\n### Anachronisms (1 error)\n- **`a_vex_at_founding`** \u2014 Vex the Silent (born year 180) is recorded as participating in the Founding of House Vyr (year 85) \u2014 95 years before his birth.\n\n### Orphans (1 warning)\n- **`o_unfinished_npc`** \u2014 Person \"Lyssa the Watcher\" exists with zero relations. Likely a world-builder placeholder.\n\n### Ontology Violations (2 warnings, same rule)\nRule `persons_born_before_280_must_die` is failing on two people who have no `died` year:\n- **`ov_maric_no_died`** \u2014 Maric Vyr (born 85)\n- **`ov_theron_no_died`** \u2014 Theron Ashveil (born 10)\n\n### Suggested priority\nThe two **errors** should be fixed first: resolve Aldric's overlapping faction memberships (decide which one applies during 260\u2013285), and correct Vex's presence at the Founding of House Vyr (either move the event, change Vex's birth year, or attribute the event to someone else alive in year 85).", "stopped_reason": "stop", "error": null, "evaluation": {